How principals affect teacher and student outcomes
Principals have complex, demanding jobs that are vital to schools, but to what extent do their actions affect school outcomes? Dr. Brendan Bartanen, K-12 education policy researcher, explores how principals and principal turnover indirectly affect outcomes like student attendance rates.
“My work shows that principals can play a big role in reducing chronic absenteeism and that districts should consider them as important actors as they work to increase attendance rates,” Bartanen said.
Bartanen is an assistant professor of K-12 education in the Department of Educational Administration and Human Resource Development. He set out to study school leadership because, despite increasing opportunities to leverage large-scale education datasets from districts and states, there remains a lack of evidence-based research on the topic.
“This is troubling from a policy perspective because we cannot provide many good recommendations about how to recruit, develop and retain high-quality leaders in schools,” Bartanen said.
Principals’ indirect influence
Teachers are the primary pathway through which principals can affect student learning. Bartanen’s prior research shows that ineffective leadership or lack of administrative support is one of the top reasons teachers decide to leave.
“The principal’s effect on student achievement is indirect — they influence the composition of the teaching staff through hiring and retention, and they create conditions in the school that allow teachers to be successful,” Bartanen said.
Another way principals influence student outcomes is by the school vision they create. They are responsible for promoting a climate where students feel safe and valued and establishing high expectations for learning.
Bartanen’s recent research identified student attendance as another outcome that principals can affect. Under the Every Student Succeeds Act, a majority of states are using chronic absenteeism, defined as missing more than 10% of school days, as a metric for school accountability.
“Beyond accountability, attendance is an important student outcome on its own,” Bartanen said. “Absences reduce the amount of instruction that students receive and there is a clear causal link between absenteeism and lower student learning.”
Bartanen described principals as “middle managers” in the school district bureaucracy that leave their positions quite frequently, resulting in high turnover. They can move laterally to a new principal position, move up for a promotion or down for a demotion.
“Given all of the ways principals matter for students, teachers and schools, the high rate of turnover should be worrisome,” Bartanen said. “Turnover rates also tend to be substantially higher in schools that serve large numbers of disadvantaged students.”
Turnover is not always bad though. Bartanen compared schools in two states for more than a decade to understand the impact of principal turnover. He compared schools that experienced principal turnover to similar schools where the same principal remained.
He found, on average, principal turnover has a short-term negative effect on student outcomes and teacher turnover. Negative effects were largest when principals were promoted to the central office or transferred to a different school. However, no negative effects were found when a principal was demoted.
“This suggests that while districts should generally try to increase the stability of leadership in schools, they should not shy away from replacing principals who are not doing a good job,” Bartanen said.
Most of Bartanen’s previous research was conducted in Tennessee, but he hopes it continues to inform school policy in more states. He said his ultimate goal is to provide high-quality, actionable evidence to policymakers and practitioners who are in a position to effect change.
“Work on school leadership has helped to drive state attention to policies that attract and retain high-quality principals, and it has also provided confirmatory evidence that the state’s early commitment to educator accountability has helped to spur continued improvement in student performance,” Bartanen said.
About the Writer
Heather is responsible for news coverage in the Department of Health and Kinesiology, as well as the Department of Educational Administration and Human Resource Development.Articles by Heather
For media inquiries, contact our Media Relations Coordinator, Ashley Green
Dr. Fuhui Tong, head of the Department of Educational Psychology, has been appointed to the Douglas J. Palmer Endowed Chair in Educational Psychology.
Dr. Jeffrey Liew, professor and associate dean of research, is among thirteen distinguished faculty members at Texas A&M to be honored as 2021 Chancellor’s Enhancing Development and Generating Excellence in Scholarship (EDGES) Fellows.
Texas A&M University’s Office of the Provost on Thursday announced Dr. Michael A. de Miranda as Interim Dean of the College of Education and Human Development.
Twenty years ago 38 passenger planes were forced to reroute to Gander, Newfoundland amid terror attacks in New York City and Washington. The small Canadian town became a refuge for nearly 6,700 stranded passengers.
Knowing how to read does not mean a person can teach reading well. A systematic review found that teacher preparation and training programs that provide extensive literacy training can improve teachers’ foundational literacy skills and improve student reading outcomes.
We typically think of summer as a time for playing and increased physical activity for children. However, this is not often the case, especially in rural and low-income areas.
Teacher attrition in Texas remains alarmingly high. Dr. Andrew Kwok in the Department of Teaching, Learning & Culture is researching ways to help seal the gap.
$3M gift supports Coaching Academy in the College of Education and Human Development at Texas A&M University
Dorothy Jersild McFerrin, through The Artie and Dorothy McFerrin Foundation, has committed a $3 million gift to the College of Education and Human Development at Texas A&M University to support and expand the services offered through the Texas A&M Coaching Academy. The academy will be re-named the Thornton-McFerrin Coaching Academy in honor of Dorothy McFerrin and John Thornton.
Texas A&M University College of Education and Human Development Dean Joyce Alexander announced Monday she will be stepping down from her position Aug. 31 to return to a faculty position.
Recent legislation passed by the 87th session of the Texas legislature will provide much-needed resources and support for students and educators heading back to classrooms after a year and a half of hybrid and remote learning.